Thrive Market vs Butcher Box


With more people buying all of their groceries online, it makes sense that there are more options for meat delivery popping up as well. If you are looking for a meat delivery service, two of the best options are Thrive Market and ButcherBox.

Thrive Market has everything you need, from whole foods to organic chicken. Most people think of Thrive Market as an online grocery store. You should be able to do all of your weekly meal shopping there, while still saving money.

ButcherBox is a bit different. They delivery 100% grass fed beef to their customers. Plus, they offer organic pork and free range chicken. This brand wants you to think of them as your neighborhood butcher, so they are mostly a meat delivery service.

Are you wondering which would be the better store for you to buy meat products from? We are going to be comparing the two, so be sure to stick around!

How Do The Companies Compare?

ButcherBox is a meat distributer- they are not a farm or grocery store. The business works with family farms and other organizations to provide quality meat to their customers. Their custom box arrives monthly, so you can think of it like an organic meat subscription box. They offer grass fed beef, organic chicken, and heritage breed pork.

Thrive Market is an online, membership based store. They are more like a Whole Foods, but 100% online. If you are trying to go out less for shopping trips, they can save you a lot of time and money. The store carries a variety of high quality food- including beef, pork, and chicken.

Both companies offer delicious, healthy food and bring it right to your door. There are some other benefits too, which we will cover further in. If you are looking for natural types of meat, both stores carry it.

However, which option is better for you? You will also want to consider cost and some other factors. The following is what else you should think about when deciding:

Cost Comparison

First of all, you want to consider your grocery budget. Thrive Market is a membership based store, which means you will need to pay them an annual fee. However, it is a very small amount. The cost is $59.95 for the year, which breaks down to a little less than $5 per month. With the membership, you gain access to thousands of healthy, organic products. All of their items are 25% to 50% lower than the retail price. This makes it so easy to save money, especially if you are switching from your local whole foods stores. If are worried about the membership, it may help to know that Thrive Market will refund you if you do not save that amount by the end of the year.

ButcherBox is more expensive. Their packages come in two sizes: Classic and Big Box. They are 9 to 14 pounds and 18 to 26 pounds, respectively. However, those costs add up fast. The Classic is $10.64 to $16.55 per pound, while the Big Box is usually $10.38 to $15 per pound. That means you will pay an average of $149 for the Classic and $270 for the Big Box each month. That is also only money for meat!

Still, their meat delivery services could be worth it for large families. If you are not eating meat with every meal at home, then it would likely not be worth it. This company also does not charge you a membership fee and your order stays fresh with dry ice.

Customer Service

Thrive Market has a wonderful customer service team. They will assist you with your first order to your last. The company has many positive online reviews to back this up. Overall, people feel that their customer service team is always available and helpful.

The same can not be said about ButcherBox, however. There are many reviews online mentioning their poor customer service. It seems that they are hard to access and canceling your monthly meat box subscription is difficult. Since it is expensive to order from them, you would want to make sure their customer service has your back- but many customers feel they do not.

So, Thrive Market would have to be the winner in this category. If you have an issue with their delivery services, they will always make it right. We recommend that you check out online reviews for both of these companies’ services for a better idea of what they are like.

Product Selection

ButcherBox offers a few different packages. You can get:

  • A mixed box with beef, chicken, and pork
  • Beef and pork
  • Beef and chicken
  • All beef items
  • Or a custom box

Unfortunately, you can not order seafood from them at this time. (If you live in the United States.) When you place an order, you can also only choose the type of meats, not the cuts. This can be a small inconvenience if you need to plan ahead for meals. The only order that allows you to make changes to the cuts is the custom box. You can select ground beef, chicken breasts, steak tips, and more.

Current Thrive Market Promo:

The ButcherBox also offers very high quality meats. All of their beef options are 100% grass fed and grass finished- never given antibiotics or hormones. Their chicken is organic and free range, and they have heritage pork. If you shop with them, you will be supporting safe, healthy, and sustainable farming.

Thrive Market has a much wider selection. You can use this site to completely replace your weekly grocery shopping trips. You will find fruits, veggies, pantry food, personal care items, snacks, and more. As for protein, you will find meat, seafood, chicken, vegetable based proteins, and several other options. Thrive offers a seafood box, which is great if you want to try some new foods, such as sockeye salmon.

Overall, we would have to say that Thrive has a much larger product selection. Both offer high quality foods, but Thrive is designed to be like grocery stores. This makes them more versatile and better able to suit your needs. ButcherBox only has meat and can only deliver once a month as a minimum- you can order with Thrive at any time.

Other Factors

When you buy a membership with Thrive, you get plenty of other benefits. We mentioned earlier that they will refund the difference if their membership does not cover your savings. However, they also offer a membership to a low income family when you sign up.

Thrive’s mission is to make ordering healthy food easier for everyone. Their products are cheap and they assist a veteran when you sign up. Plus, shipping is free whenever you spent $49 and they carry plenty of brand names. The Thrive brand products are also a lot cheaper.

The store offers a combo box, which is full of various types of meat. You will want to check it out if you are looking for tasty ways to add more protein to your diet.

What is Better Than ButcherBox?

After going through all of these comparisons, we would have to say that Thrive Market is better than ButcherBox. You can purchase beef as needed, instead of waiting for the next month to come. They also carry meat and seafood, so you have a better variety. You can find a wider selection of products with Thrive too- there are gluten free snacks, perishables, pantry goods, meat, seafood, and more. Plus, all their products are always healthy and organic.

Finally, if you need to stay in your set grocery budget, Thrive is the better choice. All of their options are 25% to 50% off of the retail price and this includes meat! You could be eating NY strip steaks after you sign up. ButcherBox is a lot more expensive. You can expect to spend at least $10 per pound of meat with them. Their meat is quality, so it might be good for a treat here and there, but it would be harder to build a budget around it. They also do not allow you to choose your cuts of meat in many orders, making Thrive better for meal planning.

If you want grass fed organic meat, we recommend that you check out Thrive Market! It can save you a lot of money in the long run. Especially when compared to a subscription box. They also will send you plenty of coupons and deals in their emails.

Can You Get Meat From Thrive Market?

You can! They have plenty of options. They have pasture raised, premium cuts, which are flash-frozen to keep them fresh. The company also offers a seafood box and plenty of other options. You will want to browse their products for yourself and what you can find.

Every diet is different, but Thrive has choices for everyone! You can sort by keto, paleo, and other sorts of diets. This makes it a lot easier to shop if you have certain restrictions to what you can eat. Overall, buying protein from Thrive is simple and convenient.

Wrap Up

So, which option do you think would better suit your needs? Both of these online shops offer high quality meats, but Thrive Market has plenty more options. They are also much cheaper and can give you more benefits.

If you are interested, be sure to visit their website. You can receive a 30 day free trial. This is the perfect amount of time to decide whether or not you are benefiting from all of the savings that they have to offer. You also can receive free shipping on your first order!

You might also be interested in:
Thrive Market vs Costco
Thrive Market vs Good Eggs
Thrive Market vs Grove
Thrive Market vs Hello Fresh
Thrive Market vs Hungryroot