Thrive Market Vs. Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides

Collagen peptides can be used for many health benefits. Studies show that ingesting peptides can benefit skin, cartilage, and joints. It also can reduce aging in the skin and help osteoporosis. But which collagen peptides are the best to take?

In this article, we will compare Thrive Market vs Vital Protein and their collagen peptide options.

Keep reading to find out the differences between them and which one will work best for your unique lifestyle.


Side-by-Side Comparison

Thrive Market PeptidesVital Proteins Collagen
  • Comes in powder (Vanilla, Chocolate, Mocha Caramel, Matcha Mint, and unflavored)
  • On-the-go packets available
  • Grass-fed cows
  • Keto-Friendly
  • Paleo
  • Sugar-free
  • Non-GMO
  • Gluten and Dairy Free
  • Ethically Sourced
  • No Hormones or Antibiotics
  • 8 essential amino acids
  • 11.1g collagen peptides per 11.8g serving
  • $22 for 10-11.7 oz package
  • Comes in powder (Unflavored, Chocolate, Dark Chocolate Blackberry, Vanilla, and Mixed Berry), crystalized coffee, creamer, gummies, and capsules
  • On-the-go options available
  • Added Hyaluronic Acid and Vitamin C
  • Option for fish peptides as well
  • Grass-fed cows
  • Whole30
  • Paleo
  • Gluten and Dairy Free
  • No added sugars
  • 8 essential amino acids
  • 20g collagen peptides for 20g serving
  • $27 for 9.33oz package (25% discount for subscriptions)

Thrive Market Pros and Cons

Thrive Market offers 11.1g of peptides per an 11.8g serving, which provides 40 calories. They provide 8 essential amino acids on top of the peptides.

Thrive prides itself on being GMO-free. They also use organic ingredients where they can and make sure all of their products are ethically sourced.

None of their cows are given hormones or antibiotics. Their products are gluten and dairy free, are Paleo and Keto friendly, and are sugar-free. They do add Monkfruit as a sweetener.

Thrive Market’s collagen comes in 5 flavors, all of which are available in tubs, or in on-the-go packets (Unflavored, Vanilla, Chocolate, Matcha Mint, and Mocha Caramel).

Thrive Market offers many products, including collagen peptides for a pretty low price. However, you cannot buy items from their website without first being a member, which costs $5 a month.

This is of course, just one product, but for a full company overview and detailed investigation of all products and service, see our full review of Thrive Market.

  • Cheap
  • Non-GMO
  • Ethically sourced
  • Responsibly raised cattle
  • 5 flavors for you to try
  • Need a membership
  • Don’t have other options for adding peptides to diet
  • Added Monkfruit sweeteners
  • No vitamin C or hyaluronic acid

Vital Proteins Pros and Cons

Vital Proteins comes with a whopping 20 grams of collagen per 2 scoop serving. They also add vitamin C, which is used to increase collagen absorption, and hyaluronic acid, which helps your body to produce collagen.

Current Thrive Market Promo:

So not only are you taking in a lot of collagen peptides, you are enticing your body to produce more of it as well.

Their website doesn’t mention being ethically sourced like Thrive’s does. However, they do responsibly raise their cattle. The cows are grass-fed and pasture-raised.

Their collagen has 8 essential amino acids, is Paleo and Whole30 approved, and is dairy and gluten free. They also avoid adding sugar into their powders and creamers, though their gummies have sugar.

Vital Proteins also comes with many options to get your peptides. The powder comes in 5 flavors (Vanilla, Chocolate, Dark Chocolate Blackberry, Unflavored, and Mixed Berry) to give you lots of flavor options.

These flavors also come in on-the-go packs. If the powder just isn’t working for you, they also offer collagen creamer in three flavors (Mocha, Vanilla, and Coconut), crystallized coffee with peptides, capsules, and gummies.

Since they also produce fish collagen peptides, there is a risk of exposure to a fish allergy, since they are made in the same factory, even when you get the beef collagen.

  • Discounts for subscribing
  • Many options to find something that works for you
  • Mostly organic products
  • Responsibly raised cattle
  • Added hyaluronic acid and vitamin C
  • Need 12 capsules a day
  • Larger serving means more calories
  • Not GMO-free
  • A little pricey compared to Thrive, even with the discount
  • Fish allergy risks

Which One is Best For You?

There is no single answer as to which product is better for everyone. If you want to have more ethically sourced and non-GMO products and don’t mind paying for a membership, then Thrive Market’s collagen peptides might be for you.

However, if you don’t want the commitment of paying for a membership, have problems taking collagen peptide powder, and want additional help absorbing and producing collagen peptides, then Vital Proteins collagen peptides are the way to go.